nebulous

It isn't about "Would", it's about "HAS HE".

it still doesnt matter nic, you gave him one hell of a harsh punishment for a honest, stupid mistake. why not just slap a NLR and a Lesson to be more careful next time? a PK is very harsh considering the honest, honest mistake of the situation and him clearly loosing a well developed character due to a stupid mistake.

Yes I did. Have a problem with it, make a report. I just did my job and judged whether a PK was valid or not.

This isn't Ban appeals, where intentions actually matter.