Sekiro definitely topping the charts for me.
The story was presented in a more straightforward way, rather than trying to interpret the 2-line descriptions for items that you may or may not find which was usually too much of a pain in the ass to interpret even if you did bother reading the the crumbs of lore. They focused on quick and fluid combat - even more so than Bloodborne. I think this emphasis on faster-paced combat made the game a bit too hard for the casual gamer but I've enjoyed the hell out of it. Stealth gameplay is a very welcome addition and makes me wonder why it wasn't a thing sooner.
All in all, 10/10 best game
Also you can skip lady butterfly pretty much because I completely missed the key to get into the room until I got to the end of the game lol