the last of us part II (potential spoilers ahead)

MaXenzie

Sexually attracted to robots
Media Developer
GTA RP Playtester
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
17,269
Nebulae
24,615
Her actor was great but she seriously had zero charm and had like, zero unique qualities other than being swole. She's a dislikable character and equally is inherently a bad character in the sense that she feels out of place in the story and the fact you're forced to play as her.

Here are a few reasons why it's hard for me to care about her/not root for Ellie to kill Abby throughout the entire game:

  1. Has the desire to kill a man for 4 years without any second thought, risking not only the lives of the people she brings with her to do so (which all die btw) but the WLF as a whole
  2. Betrays the organization that kept her fed, sheltered, and roided and kills multiple of them. Additionally gets the WLF leader killed/injured
  3. Fucks a drunk guy who has a pregnant girlfriend
  4. Would have gladly killed a pregnant woman if not for Lev

i think abby could've been a great character

if she had no involvement with ellie or joel at all
 
Reactions: List

bubblegum

you should see me in a crown
Joined
Jun 21, 2016
Messages
6,973
Nebulae
13,177
Her actor was great but she seriously had zero charm and had like, zero unique qualities other than being swole. She's a dislikable character and equally is inherently a bad character in the sense that she feels out of place in the story and the fact you're forced to play as her.

Here are a few reasons why it's hard for me to care about her/not root for Ellie to kill Abby throughout the entire game:

  1. Has the desire to kill a man for 4 years without any second thought, risking not only the lives of the people she brings with her to do so (which all die btw) but the WLF as a whole
  2. Betrays the organization that kept her fed, sheltered, and roided and kills multiple of them. Additionally gets the WLF leader killed/injured
  3. Fucks a drunk guy who has a pregnant girlfriend
  4. Would have gladly killed a pregnant woman if not for Lev

She’s a piece of shit.

She’s a soldier who kills people without remorse and is blind by the dogma of her own group. It’s only through the kids does she do anything redeeming. The point about being so strong about revenge mirrors Ellie’s desire to do the same thing. Both Ellie and Abby have an insane need to get revenge on the person they feel wronged them and it gets their friend killed in the process. But I like her as a character even if she’s unlikeable as a person.
[doublepost=1593445839][/doublepost]
One thing I've noticed is a lot of you who seem to like abby see the world in a very black and white kind of way

it’s just a game. I could say something equally generalizing about people who dislike her and it would make for unhealthy discourse.
 
Reactions: List

Blackquill

Administrator
Head Staff
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
25,697
Nebulae
110,596
Giving it a bit more thought I feel like there was a lot more potential for interactions between Joel and Abby like

I think they were going for some kind of 'reflection/mirror' metaphor since Joel lost his daughter and Abby lost her father. Maybe they were going for some kind of 'two sides of the same coin' thing. It's probably not a coinidence Abby ended up taking care of someone like Joel did with Ellie in TLOU1 but

IDK the execution seems off to me.
 
Last edited:
Reactions: List

Deleted member 28

What a pathetic string of words
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
2,285
Nebulae
1,389
She’s a piece of shit.

She’s a soldier who kills people without remorse and is blind by the dogma of her own group. It’s only through the kids does she do anything redeeming. The point about being so strong about revenge mirrors Ellie’s desire to do the same thing. Both Ellie and Abby have an insane need to get revenge on the person they feel wronged them and it gets their friend killed in the process. But I like her as a character even if she’s unlikeable as a person.
Sure, I can agree that she definitely serves her purpose as a character. She accomplishes Druckmann's goal of making the player desire revenge, which is a central point of the game. I would have been perfectly fine with her existence if it didn't feel like the game was forcing us to like her or sympathize with her, primarily regarding how we have to play as her for half the game
Giving it a bit more thought I feel like there was a lot more potential for interactions between Joel and Abbey like

I think they were going for some kind of 'reflection/mirror' metaphor since Joel lost his daughter and Abby lost her father. Maybe they were going for some kind of 'two sides of the same coin' thing. It's probably not a coinidence Abby ended up taking care of someone like Joel did with Ellie in TLOU1 but

IDK the execution seems off to me.
This is part of it too. Maybe if they didn't kill off the most crucial character in the first game and 90% of all supporting characters by the end of this one, I certainly believe that a lot of engaging interactions could have taken place. Dunno how Druckmann can say these games are about love when everyone is killing and torturing each other
 
Reactions: List

MaXenzie

Sexually attracted to robots
Media Developer
GTA RP Playtester
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
17,269
Nebulae
24,615
Giving it a bit more thought I feel like there was a lot more potential for interactions between Joel and Abbey like

I think they were going for some kind of 'reflection/mirror' metaphor since Joel lost his daughter and Abby lost her father. Maybe they were going for some kind of 'two sides of the same coin' thing. It's probably not a coinidence Abby ended up taking care of someone like Joel did with Ellie in TLOU1 but

IDK the execution seems off to me.
its made all the worse since abby does it IMMEDIATELY after joel saves her life

if the game had abby reconsider her decisions because of him saving her, there'd be a lot more depth and nuance, even if she did go through with killing him at a later date
 
Reactions: List

bubblegum

you should see me in a crown
Joined
Jun 21, 2016
Messages
6,973
Nebulae
13,177
Maybe if they didn't kill off the most crucial character in the first game

His story was done. Imo it didn't feel cheap to me. It was impactful and clearly created an emotional response from people, otherwise we wouldn't be having this discussion.

its made all the worse since abby does it IMMEDIATELY after joel saves her life

if the game had abby reconsider her decisions because of him saving her, there'd be a lot more depth and nuance, even if she did go through with killing him at a later date

The audience is supposed to condemn Abby for this action. Her saving the kids and ditching Owen is her redemption arc.
 

Deleted member 28

What a pathetic string of words
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
2,285
Nebulae
1,389
His story was done. Imo it didn't feel cheap to me. It was impactful and clearly created an emotional response from people, otherwise we wouldn't be having this discussion.
Honestly, I would have felt much better if he died in a way that at least stayed true to his character. Him making mistakes like blindly walking into a trap and giving his real name, of which he criticized Ellie for amongst other things, really doesn't make sense even if he's been living a relatively peaceful life. Those lessons are things you don't simply forget, especially considering they've saved his and Ellie's life multiple times as well as the fact that he patrols around the town and likely runs into bandits occasionally. Dumbing down his character because the writers can't think of anything more creative is disappointing

Also how does Tommy not see/care about Abby reaching for a shotgun? The more you look at these scenes and the logic behind them the more inconsistencies make themselves clear. I'm not saying the first game was flawless in this regard but it definitely wasn't this bad
 
Reactions: List

Powley

Rictal-Approved
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
16,220
Nebulae
55,373
Alright, played the game with a few friends over the part few days.

The story's still absolute garbo, even after sitting down and witnessing it not through a stream, I enjoy the Ellie and Dima dynamic, and Abby as a character has flaws but for the most part all characters fall flat and the writing is clearly rushed.

Gameplay is phenominal, reacts really well and some of the scenes like the subway chase are honestly amazing.

Graphics are a killer, looking over seatle is amazing and they really did a good number on the atmosphere of a overgrown city

Overall - 5.5, story means a lot to the last of us, and the story was weak. Its cool if you like the game but abbys agenda is just a shoehorn. Joel's story should've ended in a more dignified way. Abby and ellie are probably still alive so they can both return in druckmanns live theatre production of The last of us part 3
 
Reactions: List

Deleted member 28

What a pathetic string of words
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
2,285
Nebulae
1,389
Abby and ellie are probably still alive so they can both return in druckmanns live theatre production of The last of us part 3
I can already see it. Abby and Lev go on this journey to find the fireflies and Ellie has some lame redemption arc that eventually results in her finding and befriending Abby. Lev probably dies along the way and the remaining two of them find the fireflies and Ellie heroically sacrifices herself to develop a vaccine, even though the doctors would realistically have everything they needed from her while she was alive

sigh
 
Reactions: List

Powley

Rictal-Approved
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
16,220
Nebulae
55,373
I can already see it. Abby and Lev go on this journey to find the fireflies and Ellie has some lame redemption arc that eventually results in her finding and befriending Abby. Lev probably dies along the way and the remaining two of them find the fireflies and Ellie heroically sacrifices herself to develop a vaccine, even though the doctors would realistically have everything they needed from her while she was alive

sigh

Also abby is the surgeon

Full circle bro
 
Reactions: List

Blackquill

Administrator
Head Staff
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
25,697
Nebulae
110,596
Yahtzee also didn't like it, I'm a bit surprised I thought he'd like it since he didn't like the first game
 

Ond

Rictal-Approved
Joined
Apr 27, 2016
Messages
28,823
Nebulae
72,189
Yahtzee also didn't like it, I'm a bit surprised I thought he'd like it since he didn't like the first game
the first game is objectively good but can just not be your cup of tea

if he liked the second game i'd be concerned
 
Reactions: List

Blackquill

Administrator
Head Staff
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
25,697
Nebulae
110,596
the first game is objectively good but can just not be your cup of tea

if he liked the second game i'd be concerned
I think my favourite line from his review was him basically saying

"characters getting the shit kicked out of them doesn't make them deep or complex"
 
Reactions: List

Trains

ms paint artist extraordinaire
HL2 RP Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
14,390
Nebulae
49,084
I think my favourite line from his review was him basically saying

"characters getting the shit kicked out of them doesn't make them deep or complex"
the only show i know that this has kinda worked in is breaking bad
 

Blackquill

Administrator
Head Staff
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
25,697
Nebulae
110,596
the only show i know that this has kinda worked in is breaking bad
No character in Breaking Bad has a personality/character who's sole purpose is getting the shit kicked out of them.

Like Jesse gets beat up a shit ton but that's not why he's a deep and complex character - that's reflected in shit like his love interests, conflicts with Walt (despite being partners in crime) and a lot of other stuff you can pick out.
 
Last edited:
Reactions: List

Trains

ms paint artist extraordinaire
HL2 RP Administrator
Joined
Apr 26, 2016
Messages
14,390
Nebulae
49,084
No character in Breaking Bad has a character who's sole purpose is getting the shit kicked out of them.

Like Jesse gets beat up a shit ton but that's not why he's a deep and complex character - that's reflected in shit like his love interests, conflicts with Walt (despite being partners in crime) and a lot of other stuff you can pick out.
ye exactly

my point is, to me it helps you feel sympathetic towards him, because you know jesse tries his best to do well and be a good person and yet he can’t help but get the shit beat out of him and land in deep shit all the time

obviously there’s a lot more to it than that, but with tlou2 i feel like they kinda just assumed that “oh well likeable character getting beaten up = sympathy right guys”

but they forgot to make the character likeable omegalul